Thirty-seven times last season, Boston College goalie John Muse left the ice, changed out of his uniform and had trouble walking out of the rink.
He was playing with a torn labrum in his right hip, an injury he certainly felt throughout the entirety of the 2008-09 season. After all, he was given a stinging reminder every time he extended his right leg to make a save. But Muse kept his iron-man streak alive, starting all 37 of BC’s games despite the injury.
The pain started at the tail end of the 2007-08 season - Muse’s freshman year, in which he started all 44 of the team’s games - but he thought nothing of it, particularly because the Eagles were driving toward a national championship and Muse’s stellar play was a major reason why.
He was named to the Hockey East All-Tournament Team after going 4-0 with a 1.28 goals-against average and .959 save percentage, and he was selected to the Frozen Four All-Tournament Team with a 2-0 record, 1.00 goals-against average and .961 save percentage. All the while, Muse thought he was playing with a strained groin, but he had the makings of a torn labrum.
“It wasn’t excruciating pain,” said Muse, who is now in his junior season. “It hurt on certain movements. When I’d overextend, I’d get a pinching in my hip, and mostly it was afterward when it hurt. It would hurt to walk pretty much every time after I played in a game.
“It started to hurt at the very end of my freshman year. It was giving me problems, and we thought it was a groin strain or something along those lines. That summer [in 2008], I ended up getting mono, and I think I was out for six weeks. I figured once I came back [the groin pain] would be all gone, and I would be healthy again. But when I started playing again, I had the same pain. I think I suddenly realized I should have it checked out. Once we had an MRI done on it, they determined there was something wrong inside and it wasn’t just the groin problem.”
Muse had the MRI during Boston College’s Christmas break in 2008, which was already 16 games into the season. At that point, Muse had a 2.58 goals-against average, which was 11th among all Hockey East goaltenders, and his .907 save percentage was tied for 10th. While his numbers suffered, it’s fair to note BC’s defense fell off from its championship run, too.
When asked if he was diagnosed with a torn labrum after the MRI, Muse responded, “We didn’t really go over what it was. I think they knew, but I wasn’t planning on getting it fixed during the middle of the season just because I wanted to finish off the regular season and figure out what I could do to make it better. I didn’t really pursue anything until after the season was over.”
Muse said it was a pretty consistent pain throughout the season that didn’t really worsen through time - “It was torn pretty early on, and I don’t think it got worse as the season went on or anything.” - but he didn’t think it really hindered his performance. After all, the kid backstopped a national championship on the balky hip. Because of that, he also didn’t want to make a big deal of it around the locker room.
“I tried to keep it quiet,” Muse said. “I tried not to let it bother me because I feel like if I go and tell everybody how much it hurts then I would start to realize how much it hurts. I was just keeping it quiet, trying to keep it out of my mind.”
The Eagles’ 2008-09 season ended with a 3-2 loss to Boston University in the Hockey East semifinals. The Terries scored three goals during a league-record 44-second stretch in the second period. BU forward Zach Cohen started the scoring with a couple of nice moves before backhanding the puck past Muse’s outstretched left skate, which may have caused some discomfort, and BU added two decisive goals within the next minute.
When it was determined the Eagles wouldn’t get a berth in the NCAA tournament, Muse was sent to a doctor in Boston who has worked with Tommy Cross’s knee issues. Coincidentally, a week before Muse’s visit, the doctor diagnosed former New Hampshire goalie Kevin Regan - who was playing with the Providence Bruins at the time - with a torn labrum. The doctors told Muse it has become a fairly common injury, and until medical knowledge improved, it was being misdiagnosed for years as a groin injury.
“When I went in there,” Muse said of the doctor’s office, “within five minutes of seeing me, he knew exactly what was wrong and what needed to be done.”
BC coach Jerry York gave Regan’s number to Muse, who called Regan the day before his own surgery. Regan gave him some advice on how to handle the situation and what to expect after the surgery.
Muse underwent surgery April 30, about five and a half weeks after BC’s season ended at the Garden. He was on crutches for “a tough nine weeks” afterward and finally put some skates on a week after he tossed the crutches aside. It wasn’t until the final week in August when he started taking shots in net.
“It was awesome,” Muse said. “I took a little over five months from completely not playing hockey. That’s pretty tough when you’re used to playing hockey every single day. It was really nice getting back out there finally.”
Even when he was away from the rink, Muse was working out every day with the Boston College training staff. He worked on upper-body strength while waiting for his hip to heal, and then he moved toward stabilizing his right hip. Still, Muse was kept on a very strict schedule, as the team trainers made sure he didn’t overwork himself, which could have led to a setback. Even now, his workout routine is being monitored until the hip fully heals.
Before the season, York anticipated giving Muse a much lighter workload and said he would rely more on backup goalies Parker Milner and Chris Venti. To date, though, Muse has started seven of BC’s eight games, while Milner has played once.
Muse said his right hip was “pretty sore” at the beginning, but things are improving as the season has progressed. He is 3-3-1 with a 2.85 goals-against average and .885 save percentage.
More impressive than Muse’s numbers is his resiliency. Boston College has played on back-to-back nights on two occasions this season, and Muse has played both games each time. He might be ahead of the doctor’s initial prognosis, which called for four to six months of recovery time, but Muse is right on schedule with his own plan.
“I knew I was going to be ready for the beginning of the season,” said Muse, who has played in the Eagles’ last five games. “They told me if I did everything I was told to throughout the summer then I would be ready for the season. I was there working every single day during the summer so I could get ready and be on the ice for the first game. Luckily, everything worked out and went according to plan, and I was able to play in the first game.”
Muse still isn’t pain free, but he’s getting there. He has obviously passed the physical constraints, and the emotional tests are way back in the rearview mirror. For a young athlete who has already accomplished so much, that original gut check can be pretty difficult to take. The mind can play some crazy games on a person who was once indestructible.
Now that Muse has been reconstructed, the Eagles have their workhorse in net and can put themselves in position to return to the national tournament.
“There’s always that thought that it might not heal correctly and I could be out for more than four months,” Muse said. “I could miss the first half of the season or something like that. But luckily, everything has gone according to plan so far, and hopefully it continues that way.
“It was a little difficult just knowing that I was having pretty major surgery on my hip, which is something I use every time I’m on the ice. It’s something that I need to be healthy, and I wasn’t too nervous about it afterward because I saw how many people had gotten the surgery and come back healthy.”